Roofing Choices: A Comparison of Essentials vs. Peace of Mind vs. BulletProof vs. Stone-Coated Steel Packages
Choosing the Right Roof: Why It Matters
When considering a new roof, a thorough shingle comparison is essential to ensure you select the best option for your home and region.
There is a wide range of types of roofing materials and roofing types available, each offering unique benefits and considerations. Exploring these options helps you understand which materials and styles best suit your needs.
Exploring your roofing choices helps clarify what’s best for your home’s long-term durability and design. Understanding different roofing packages is key to aligning protection, cost, and performance.
Your roof isn’t just a layer of protection—it’s a long-term investment. The type of shingles you choose influences your home’s durability, resale value, energy efficiency, and insurance premiums. Aesthetic appeal is also a key factor, as the right choice can enhance your home’s visual attractiveness and curb appeal. Whether you’re preparing for hurricane season, hailstorms, or simply upgrading for aesthetics, your decision will impact your property for decades.
At Reimagine Roofing, we understand that comparing options can be overwhelming. That’s why we’ve broken down four top-performing roofing packages—Essentials, Peace of Mind, BulletProof, and Stone-Coated Steel—to help you make the right choice for your home and your budget. Making informed decisions means considering key factors such as cost, durability, and design preferences to ensure the best outcome for your investment.
Schedule a free roof inspection and get an estimate in less than 24 hours using our Fast Quote Tool.
Understanding the Roofing Packages
Each roofing package differs in terms of warranty, materials, impact resistance, overall value, and the quality of roofing materials used. Let’s dive into what sets each one apart.
Selecting the right package is a crucial step in any roofing project.
Essentials Roofing Package: Budget-Friendly Protection
Key Features:
- Warranty: 10 years
- Underlayment: Mechanically-Fastened
- Impact Resistance: Class 3
- Wind Rating: 110 MPH
- Investment: $
- Additional Benefits: Includes 5 sheets of plywood
Essentials shingles are the entry-level choice, ideal for homeowners seeking basic protection without a high upfront cost. Though they offer solid Class 3 impact resistance and support wind speeds up to 110 MPH, they’re best suited for moderate climates and shorter-term investments.
If you’re flipping a home or need to replace a roof on a rental property, the Essentials tier can be a solid economical roofing package.
Peace of Mind Roofing Package: Balanced Performance
Key Features:
- Warranty: 25 years
- Underlayment: Premium HT-SA
- Impact Resistance: Class 3
- Wind Rating: 130 MPH
- Investment: $$
- Additional Benefits: Includes 10 sheets of plywood
Peace of Mind offers a significant upgrade over Essentials. The longer warranty and upgraded self-adhered underlayment add resilience and reliability. It’s ideal for homeowners who plan to stay in their home long-term and want protection from stronger winds and storm systems.
Reimagine Roofing recommends this roofing package for most standard residential properties across the U.S.
BulletProof Roofing Package: Enhanced Durability for Harsh Climates
Key Features:
- Warranty: 25 years
- Underlayment: Premium HT-SA
- Impact Resistance: Class 4
- Wind Rating: 130 MPH
- Investment: $$$
- Additional Benefits: Includes 35 sheets of plywood
- Insurance Premiums: Decreased
With Class 4 impact resistance—the highest rating available—BulletProof shingles are engineered for homes in hail-prone regions. The generous inclusion of 35 plywood sheets adds substantial reinforcement, making this roofing package ideal for severe weather zones.
If you’ve filed insurance claims in the past or live in areas that receive regular wind or hail damage, this shingle system can pay for itself through reduced insurance premiums and fewer repairs.
Stone-Coated Steel Roofing Package: Premium Protection and Curb Appeal
Key Features:
- Warranty: 50 years
- Underlayment: Premium HT-SA
- Impact Resistance: Class 4
- Wind Rating: 130 MPH
- Investment: $$$$$
- Additional Benefits: Includes 50 sheets of plywood
- Insurance Premiums: Decreased
- Home Value: Increased
- Curb Appeal: Increased
Stone-Coated Steel is in a class of its own. Combining the beauty of traditional tile or shake with steel’s strength and longevity, this roofing package offers the best of both worlds.
It’s particularly attractive for forever homes, historic properties, or those in HOA-regulated communities. With a 50-year warranty and unmatched weather resistance, this roof is built to last.
Roofing Choices: Warranty Comparison
- Essentials: 10 years — best for short-term ownership or flips; entry-level packages may only come with limited warranties, which could be a consideration for short-term homeowners
- Peace of Mind / BulletProof: 25 years — ideal for most long-term homeowners
- Stone-Coated Steel: 50 years — premium lifetime solution; premium packages offer some of the best warranties in the industry
Longer warranties also mean higher ROI, especially if you plan to stay in your home or sell it later with a transferrable roof warranty.
Underlayment: What’s Beneath the Surface Matters
- Mechanically-Fastened (Essentials): Stapled or nailed synthetic felt. Adequate for mild climates. Underlayment can also contribute to the roof’s insulation properties, enhancing energy efficiency and comfort.
- Premium HT-SA (All Others): A self-adhered high-temp underlayment offering superior water resistance, longevity, and adhesion. This underlayment helps prevent leaks by providing a strong barrier against water intrusion and effectively manages water runoff, reducing the risk of water accumulation on the roof.
Premium HT-SA performs better under extreme heat, minimizes leakage risk, strengthens the roof deck, and supports overall insulation for improved energy efficiency.
Wind & Storm Resistance Breakdown
| Shingle Type | Wind Rating |
|---|---|
| Essentials | 110 MPH |
| Peace of Mind | 130 MPH |
| BulletProof | 130 MPH |
| Stone-Coated Steel | 130 MPH |
In hurricane zones or windy states like Florida, Texas, and the Carolinas, anything under 130 MPH may not suffice. These packages are designed to withstand high winds. Peace of Mind and up are recommended.
Certain roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles and metal roofs, are better suited for pitched roofs, and wind resistance can vary depending on the roof slope.
Impact Resistance: Class 3 vs. Class 4
- Class 3: Withstands 1.75” steel ball drop without fracturing (Essentials, Peace of Mind)
- Class 4: Withstands 2” steel ball drop — the highest rating (BulletProof, Stone-Coated Steel). These shingles are constructed with multiple layers to provide superior impact protection.
Class 4 resistance is highly recommended for hail-prone areas like Colorado, Oklahoma, and North Texas. It also increases eligibility for insurance discounts.
Investment Comparison
| Shingle Type | Investment Level |
|---|---|
| Essentials | $ |
| Peace of Mind | $$ |
| BulletProof | $$$ |
| Stone-Coated Steel | $$$$$ |
Roofing costs are typically calculated per square foot, allowing homeowners to estimate total project expenses based on the size of their roof.
Essentials: Budget-friendly
Peace of Mind: Balance between cost and protection
BulletProof: High-value protection
Stone-Coated Steel: High-end, luxury, long-lasting
Insurance Benefits
Many insurance providers offer premium reductions for Class 4 roofing systems like BulletProof and Stone-Coated Steel. Additionally, choosing a roofing system with enhanced underlayment and wind resistance can reduce your risk profile significantly. Selecting a roofing system tailored to your specific roofing needs and relying on a contractor with extensive roofing experience can further help maximize your insurance benefits.
Ask Reimagine Roofing for guidance—we’ll provide supporting documents for your insurance claim or premium review.
Roofing Choices: Increasing Home Value & Curb Appeal
Stone-Coated Steel enhances architectural appeal and home value. These roofs offer:
- Stunning textures and finishes
- Compatibility with a variety of home styles
- Longer lifespan to attract buyers
Homeowners can also choose from a variety of shingle colors and styles, including traditional shingles and wood shingles, to further enhance the aesthetic appeal and value of their home.
BulletProof shingles also enhance resale potential due to their impact rating and extended coverage.
Roofing Choices: Sustainability & Environmental Impact
Metal and impact-rated shingles reduce environmental impact by lasting longer and requiring fewer replacements. Some options (like steel) are recyclable, making them both eco friendly and environmentally friendly choices that help minimize ecological impact.
Additionally, cool roof coatings and heat-reflective technology make roofing materials more energy efficient by reflecting the sun’s rays and withstanding high temperatures, which is especially beneficial in hot climates. Certain roofing systems are also compatible with solar panels, allowing homeowners to generate electricity and further enhance sustainability. Some roofing materials are specifically designed to resist damage from UV rays, increasing their longevity and performance.
Installation and Maintenance: What to Expect and How to Care for Your New Roof
When you invest in a new roof, understanding the installation process and ongoing maintenance is crucial for maximizing the value and performance of your roofing material. At Reimagine Roofing, we believe that a well-informed homeowner is best equipped to protect their investment and enjoy peace of mind for years to come.
Why Homeowners Choose Reimagine Roofing as their Top Roofer
Choosing the right shingles is one thing—choosing the right contractor is everything. With extensive experience in the roofing industry, Reimagine Roofing is equipped to handle a wide range of roofing projects, from new installations to replacements. Our comprehensive services include not only full roof replacements but also minor repairs to address small issues and ensure long-term roof performance. We specialize in:
- Matching the right roof to your needs and climate
- Transparent pricing with free roof inspections
- Estimates delivered in under 24 hours
- Full support for insurance claims and code compliance
- Licensed and insured professionals with national reach
We’re not just replacing your roof—we’re protecting your investment.
Get Started with a Free Roof Inspection Today
Still unsure which shingle/metal option is best for your home? That’s where we come in. Book a free, no-obligation inspection and let our experts walk you through your choices, allowing homeowners to make confident, informed decisions about their roofing needs.
✅ Use our Fast Quote Tool to get your roofing estimate in less than 24 hours
✅ Learn how you can qualify for insurance discounts
✅ Explore high-performance materials and finishes tailored to your property
Schedule your free inspection today and make the smart move with Reimagine Roofing.
FAQs
- Which shingles are best for hail-prone states?
BulletProof or Stone-Coated Steel with Class 4 impact rating. - What’s the most budget-friendly option?
Essentials, ideal for temporary homes or rentals. - Do any of these qualify for insurance discounts?
Yes—BulletProof and Stone-Coated Steel may lower premiums due to Class 4 rating. - Is underlayment important?
Yes. Premium HT-SA adds durability, leak resistance, and better performance in heat. - Do I need to replace the decking?
Higher-tier options include more plywood (up to 50 sheets) to reinforce the deck. - What are the pros and cons of other materials like natural slate and real slate?
Natural slate and real slate offer exceptional durability, fire resistance, and a classic appearance, but they are heavy, expensive, require skilled installation, and may need reinforcement of the roof structure. - How does roof structure affect material choice?
Heavy materials like real slate or concrete tiles may require additional support for your roof structure, while lightweight options like composite or asphalt shingles usually do not. - Are some roofing materials more time consuming or require more maintenance?
Yes, wood roofing is time consuming to maintain and needs regular upkeep. Concrete tiles also require more maintenance, such as periodic resealing due to water absorption.
